Skip to content

How to Analyze a Rental Property Deal in 15 Minutes

The 15-Minute Framework

Most deals are not worth pursuing. The key is knowing which ones deserve your time and which ones to skip. This framework lets you screen any property in 15 minutes or less.

Minutes 1 to 3: The 1% Test

Monthly rent divided by purchase price. If it is below 0.8%, move on unless you have a specific appreciation or value-add thesis.

Minutes 4 to 7: Estimate Monthly Cash Flow

  • Gross rent: Check Zillow, Rentometer, or local comps
  • Mortgage payment: Use an online calculator (current rates, 20% down, 30-year fixed)
  • Taxes: Check county records (divide annual by 12)
  • Insurance: Estimate $100 to $150/month for a single-family
  • Vacancy: 8% of gross rent
  • Maintenance: 10% of gross rent
  • Management: 10% of gross rent (even if self-managing, account for your time)

Minutes 8 to 10: Calculate Net Operating Income

Gross rent minus all expenses (except mortgage) equals NOI. Then subtract your mortgage payment. Positive number? Keep going. Negative? Walk away or renegotiate.

Minutes 11 to 13: Check the Neighborhood

Look at population growth, job market, school ratings, and crime stats. A great deal in a declining area is not a great deal.

Minutes 14 to 15: Make Your Decision

Does this property meet your minimum cash flow target ($100 to $200/month per unit)? Is the neighborhood trending positively? If yes to both, it deserves a deeper dive.

Download our Deal Analysis Spreadsheet for the full detailed analysis, or learn the complete framework in the First Property Playbook.

Enjoy this article?

Subscribe to get weekly insights on faith, family, and generational wealth.

Subscribe Now

Watch Esther in Action

Stay at the Table

Weekly insights on faith, family, real estate, and building generational wealth.

🎧
Someone just subscribed!
Select an episode to play
The Broker's Table Podcast
0:00 0:00